MOURC Proceedings Archive - Gulls, Terns Accepted
Duplicates
This is the 1981 to present Records Committee Proceedings archive for
The Loon, journal of the Minnesota Ornithologists' Union.
The last 2 years are available to MOU members.
Families
Whistling-Ducks, Geese, Swans, Ducks
New World Quail
Partridge, Pheasants, Grouse, Turkeys
Grebes
Pigeons, Doves
Cuckoos
Nightjars
Swifts
Hummingbirds
Rails, Gallinules, Coots
Limpkin
Cranes
Stilts, Avocets
Plovers
Sandpipers
Jaegers
Alcids
Gulls, Terns
Loons
Shearwaters and Petrels
Storks
Frigatebirds
Boobies and Gannets
Anhingas
Cormorants
Pelicans
Bitterns, Herons, Egrets, Night-Herons
Ibises
New World Vultures
Osprey
Kites, Accipiters, Hawks, Eagles
Barn Owls
Screech-Owls, Owls
Woodpeckers
Caracaras, Falcons
Flycatchers
Vireos
Shrikes
Jays, Nutcrackers, Magpies, Crows
Martins, Swallows
Kinglets
Silky-flycatchers
Nuthatches
Wrens
Thrashers, Mockingbirds
Dippers
Thrushes
Old World Flycatchers
Old World Sparrows
Pipits
Finches
Longspurs and Snow Buntings
Towhees, Sparrows
Yellow-breasted Chat
Blackbirds, Orioles
Warblers
Tanagers, Cardinals, Grosbeaks

Proceedings
Species: Gulls, Terns
Black-legged Kittiwake
Ivory Gull
Sabine's Gull
Black-headed Gull
Little Gull
Ross's Gull
Laughing Gull
Short-billed Gull
California Gull
Iceland Gull
Lesser Black-backed Gull
Slaty-backed Gull
Glaucous-winged Gull
Great Black-backed Gull
Least Tern
Gull-billed Tern
[White-winged Tern]
Common Tern
Arctic Tern
Forster's Tern
[Royal Tern]
Sandwich Tern
Elegant Tern
[Black Skimmer]

Black-legged Kittiwake (C) (Rissa tridactyla)Start Date 0000-00-00
RefFirstLastLocationCounty23CommentStatus
1MOU1964-12-151964-12-16Knife RiverLakeThe Loon 37:59Accepted
avian
information
1964-12-151964-12-16Lake12/15-16 Lake (first state record) (first county record)
12-15 (JCG) and 12-16 (BL), Knife River, Lake Co, 1 imm seen at close range, excellent black & white photos obtained by JCG. First Minnesota record.
37:59-601965indexFirst Kittiwake for Lake Superior
48:1891976indexBlack-legged Kittiwake at Mille Lacs Lake
2MOU1976-10-30Mille Lacs Lake (Garrison)Crow WingThe Loon 48:189Accepted
avian
information
1976-10-30Crow Wing10/30 Crow Wing (second state record) (first county record)
10-30 Garrison, Crow Wing Co. (1 imm.) TS, JG, PE; second state record.
54:421978-09-12Stoney PointSt. Louis(vote 5-2, with 6-1 required for acceptance) Since the size of this immature gull was not mentioned, the minority was of the opinion that the possibility of Little Gull was not precluded by the plumage description. (M.O.R.C. had previously voted on this record in 1978, but the result had been inconclusive.) Not Accepted
3MOU1979-11-24Grand MaraisCookThe Loon 53:52Accepted
4MOU1980-11-20Lakeside Twp., near Mille Lacs LakeAitkinThe Loon 53:55Accepted
avian
information
1980-11-20Aitkin11/20 Aitkin (third state record) (first county record)
11-20 Aitkin TS (1 found d.o.r.)
53:52-531981indexImmature Black-legged Kittiwake at Grand Marais
53:551981indexMinnesota's Fifth Black-legged Kittiwake Record
54:421981-08-28DuluthSt. Louis(vote 2-5) It was felt that this immature gull was not seen well enough to rule out Sabine's Gull, which can have a similar appearing wing pattern when seen under unfavorable conditions as was the case here. Not Accepted
54:1471981-11-11German LakeIsanti(vote 2-5) The identification of this adult gull was based on "all black" wing tips, a "yellowish" bill, and "darkish" feet seen in flight. However, sub-adult Ring-billed Gulls also can have solid black wing tips, and the bill and feet colors described are too vague and were only seen while the gull was in flight when such features are difficult to observe. Not Accepted
54:1901982indexFirst Spring Record of a Black-legged Kittiwake
5MOU1982-05-271982-05-30DuluthSt. LouisThe Loon 54:190Accepted
avian
information
1982-05-271982-05-30St. Louis5/27-30 St. Louis (first spring record)
5-27 Park Point, Duluth KE, FL, SDM (1-2nd yr), 5-28 Duluth RJ, MH, 5-30 Duluth KE. See Notes of Interest, THE LOON, Vol. 54, No. 3, p. 190.
55:1231983indexBlack-legged Kittiwake in Roseau County
55:1791983indexBlack-legged Kittiwake at Stoney Point
55:1811983indexBlack-legged Kittiwake in Carlton County
656:171983-06-11Greenbush Roseau(vote 7-0; Loon 55:123). Accepted
avian
information
1983-06-11Roseau6/11 Roseau (fourth state record) (first county record)
One immature, 6/11, sewage lagoons, Greenbush, Roseau Co. (Loon 55:123).
756:171983-09-111983-09-17Stoney PointSt. Louis(vote 7-0; Loon 55:179). Accepted
MOU1983-09-111983-09-18Stoney PointSt. LouisThe Loon 55:179Accepted
8MOU1983-11-20Kettle RiverCarltonThe Loon 55:181Accepted
avian
information
1983-11-20Carlton11/20 Carlton (fifth state record) (first county record)
9/11 to 9/18 Stoney Point, St. Louis Co. (one imm.) MH, KC, M.ob. (The Loon 55:179), 11/20 Carlton (one imm.) JP/AM (The Loon 55:181).
56:2711984indexBlack-legged Kittiwake at Leech Lake
57:1191984-07-11Leech LakeCass(record withdrawn by the observers). This record , which was originally accepted on a 6-1 vote and published (The Loon 56:271), was reconsidered by the observers and withdrawn after it was pointed out that the bird may actually have been a juvenile Common Black-headed Gull, rather than a first summer (i.e . , one-year old) kittiwake. All the details noted could fit either species, except for the "slightly forked tail"; however, viewing conditions were unfavorable , the tail shape on a kittiwake is difficult to see, and one of the observers never saw the tail shape. This observer, who now feels the bird was more likely a Common Black-headed, also had the impression of a brownish back and relatively long legs both of which would preclude kittiwake . Not Accepted
957:1191984-10-26Stoney PointSt. Louis(vote 7-0). Accepted
avian
information
1988-11-08Dakota11/8 Dakota (sixth state record) (first county record)
11/8 Hastings, Dakota-Washington Co. JD., TF (The Loon 60:187-88).
60:187-1881988indexBlack-legged Kittiwake at Hastings
1061:101988-11-08Hastings WashingtonDakota(vote 7-0; The Loon 60:187-188). Accepted
avian
information
1988-11-08Washington11/8 Washington (seventh state record) (first county record)
11/8 Hastings, Dakota-Washington Co. JD., TF (The Loon 60:187-88).
1161:1211988-12-031988-12-05Black Dog L.DakotaHennepin(vote 7-0; The Loon 61:45-46). Accepted
MOU1988-12-031988-12-08Black Dog Lake, Minnesota RiverDakotaHennepinThe Loon 61:45-46Accepted
avian
information
1988-12-031988-12-08Dakota12/3-8 Dakota (eighth state record) (second county record)
One at Black Dog Lake, Dakota Co. 12/3 to 12/5 m.ob. (The Loon 61 :3-4,45-46).
avian
information
1988-12-031988-12-08Hennepin12/3-8 Hennepin (ninth state record) (first county record)
One at Black Dog Lake, Dakota Co. 12/3 to 12/5 m.ob. (The Loon 61 :3-4,45-46).
61:3-41989indexA Gathering of Gulls
61:45-461989indexBlack-legged Kittiwake at Black Dog Lake
61:84-851989indexBlack-legged Kittiwake at Bemidji
1261:1211989-04-20Bemidji Beltrami(vote 7-0; The Loon 61:84-85). Accepted
avian
information
1989-04-20Beltrami4/20 Beltrami (tenth state record) (first county record)
4/20 Bemidji, Beltrami Co. DJ (The Loon 61 :84-85).
63:1431991indexBlack-legged Kittiwake in Winona County
63:2791991indexA Black-legged Kittiwake in Cook County
13MOU1991-03-30Mississippi River at Lock & Dam #7WinonaThe Loon 63:143Accepted
avian
information
1991-03-30Winona3/30 Winona (eleventh state record) (first county record)
Only report: 3/30 Winona, Winona Co. CCB (The Loon 63:143).
1464:151991-10-261991-10-27TofteCook(vote 7-0; The Loon 63:279). Accepted
MOU1991-10-261991-10-27TofteCookThe Loon 63:279Accepted
1564:1381991-11-03DuluthSt. Louis(vote 6-1; The Loon 64:123). Accepted
1664:1381991-11-18Temperance River S. P.Cook(vote 7-0; The Loon 64:124). Accepted
64:1231992indexBlack-legged Kittiwake at Duluth
64:1241992indexBlack-legged Kittiwake in Cook County
1767:1651994-12-26DuluthSt. Louis(The Loon 67:110). Accepted
avian
information
1994-12-26St. Louis12/26 St. Louis (second winter record)
One first-winter individual reported on 12/26 at Duluth, St. Louis County PS (this is the third winter record, not the second as erroneously stated in The Loon 67:110).
67:1101995indexBlack-legged Kittiwake in Duluth
67:248-2491995indexBlack-legged Kittiwake at Black Dog Lake
1868:581995-09-16DuluthSt. Louis Accepted
1968:1641995-11-12near Orwell Wildlife Management AreaOtter Tail(The Loon 68:71). Accepted
avian
information
1995-11-12Otter Tail11/12 Otter Tail (twelfth state record) (first county record)
Reported 9/16 St. Louis (first-winter) AH (The Loon 68:131); picked up 11/12 near Orwell W.M.A., Otter Tail (first-winter) fide GO, SDM (The Loon 68:71).
2068:1641995-12-011995-12-02Black Dog LakeDakota(The Loon 68:71-73). Accepted
avian
information
1995-12-011995-12-02Dakota12/1-2 Dakota (thirteenth state record) (third county record)
First-winter individual reported 12/1–2 at Black Dog Lake, Dakota Co. BF, mob (The Loon 67:248–249, 68:71–73).
68:14-341996indexGull Migration in the Twin Cities
68:711996indexBlack-legged Kittiwake in Otter Tail County
68:71-721996indexBlack-legged Kittiwake in Dakota County
68:1311996indexBlack-legged Kittiwake in Duluth
2169:281996-09-28BenaCass(The Loon 69:44). Accepted
avian
information
1996-09-281996-11-10Cass9/28, 11/10 Cass (fourteenth state record) (first county record)
Two reports from Lake Winnibigoshish, possibly the same bird, 9/28 Cass PS (The Loon 69:44) and 11/10 Cass PS (The Loon 68:247).
2269:281996-11-10BenaCass(The Loon 68:247). Accepted
2370:441997-11-021997-11-17Grand MaraisCook(photo record #97-75, vote 7-0, The Loon 69:222- 223). Accepted
2470:441997-11-27Two HarborsLake(record #97-85, vote 7-0). Accepted
avian
information
1997-11-27Lake11/27 Lake (fifteenth state record) (second county record)
One bird in first-winter plumage 11/2–17 Cook (Grand Marais) KE et al. (The Loon 69:222–223) was possibly the same individual seen 11/27 Lake (Two Harbors) MT, MD.
2571:361998-09-241998-09-26DuluthSt. Louis(record #98-82, vote 7-0). Accepted
2672:401999-11-21Grand MaraisCook(record #99-72, vote 6-1, The Loon 72:59). Accepted
2773:1682000-10-21Grand MaraisCook(record #2001-09, vote 7-0, The Loon 73:124- 125). Accepted
2873:352000-10-302000-11-02Two HarborsLake(record #2000-89, vote 7-0). Accepted
avian
information
2000-10-302000-11-02Lake10/30-11/2 Lake (third county record)
Single first-winter birds discovered 10/21 Cook (Grand Marais) †DBz, †CRG et al. (The Loon 73:124–125); 10/30 and 11/2 Lake (Agate Bay, Two Harbors) †PHS, †AXH, †JWL (The Loon 73:129). All reports may refer to the same individual, but good numbers were noted elsewhere on the Great Lakes this fall, e.g., a total of 11 during the fall season at Whitefish Point on eastern L. Superior.
2974:1612001-11-12near Grand MaraisCook(record #2002-10, vote 7-0, The Loon 74:122). Clearly identifiable photos of this juvenile/first-winter bird were included in the documentation. Accepted
3074:1612001-11-30DuluthSt. Louis(record #2002-12, vote 7-0, The Loon 74:176-177). There is the possibility that this and the other two kittiwake records (2002-10 and 13) all refer to the same individual. Accepted
3174:1612001-12-02near SandstonePine(record #2002-13, vote 7-0, The Loon 74:58-59). This gull was found under unusual circumstances: it was feeding on a deer carcass on the shoulder of Interstate 35. Accepted
avian
information
2001-12-02Pine12/2 Pine (first county record)
First-winter individual found feeding on road-killed deer along I-35 on 12/2 Pine (near Sandstone) †TPW (The Loon 74:58–59).
3278:1262005-12-04Cenakio Lake, Coon Rapids Dam Regional ParkAnoka(record #2005-088, vote 7-0). Accepted
avian
information
2005-12-04Anoka12/4 Anoka (first county record)
Two accepted records, possibly involving the same 1st-winter bird: 12/4 Anoka (Cenakio Lake, Coon Rapids Dam R.P.) †GP, 12/7–24 Dakota/Hennepin (west outflow of Black Dog Lake) ph. †JPM, m.ob. The latter was also documented by †CMB, ph. DAC, †PCC, ph. †AXH, †PSV as it lingered for a record 18 days and provided the first record for a Minnesota Christmas Bird Count (Bloomington CBC).
3378:1262005-12-072005-12-24Black Dog LakeDakotaHennepin(record #2005-082, vote 7-0). Both of these records referred to firstFall 2006 129 winter kittiwakes and may have involved the same individual; the latter was photographed by many observers. Accepted
avian
information
2005-12-072006-01-01Dakota12/7-24, 1/1 Dakota (fourth county record)
Two accepted records, possibly involving the same 1st-winter bird: 12/4 Anoka (Cenakio Lake, Coon Rapids Dam R.P.) †GP, 12/7–24 Dakota/Hennepin (west outflow of Black Dog Lake) ph. †JPM, m.ob. The latter was also documented by †CMB, ph. DAC, †PCC, ph. †AXH, †PSV as it lingered for a record 18 days and provided the first record for a Minnesota Christmas Bird Count (Bloomington CBC).
avian
information
2005-12-072005-12-24Hennepin12/7-24 Hennepin (second county record)
Two accepted records, possibly involving the same 1st-winter bird: 12/4 Anoka (Cenakio Lake, Coon Rapids Dam R.P.) †GP, 12/7–24 Dakota/Hennepin (west outflow of Black Dog Lake) ph. †JPM, m.ob. The latter was also documented by †CMB, ph. DAC, †PCC, ph. †AXH, †PSV as it lingered for a record 18 days and provided the first record for a Minnesota Christmas Bird Count (Bloomington CBC).
3479:1232007-01-112007-01-12Lake PepinWabasha(record #2007-010, vote 7-0). Record late by more than two weeks (26 December 1994, The Loon 67:110). Accepted
avian
information
2007-01-112007-01-12Wabasha1/11-12 Wabasha (first county record)
Record late by more than two weeks (26 December 1994, The Loon 67:110) was a first-winter bird 1/11–12 Wabasha (Lake Pepin) †DBz, †JWH.
81:1152008-11-08White Bear LakeRamsey(record #2009-003, vote 2-5). Not Accepted
3582:32009-10-31Superior EntrySt. Louis(record #2009-049, vote 7-0). Ninth county record. None of the state's 35 records refers to adults. Accepted
avian
information
2010-11-212010-11-22Lac qui Parle11/21, 22 Lac qui Parle (first county record)
Immature found 11/21 (third earliest date south) Lac qui Parle (Big Stone N.W.R.) ph. BJU and relocated the next day 11/22 RAE.
3684:32011-12-132011-12-17Canal Park, DuluthSt. Louis(record #2011-042, vote 7-0). The 17 December 2011 photo (taken during the Duluth Christmas Bird Count) is diagnostic, as is the description from the original observer. first-cycle;Accepted
avian
information
2011-12-132011-12-18St. Louis12/13, 17, 18 St. Louis (third winter record)
Two reports St. Louis (Canal Park) of probably the same first-cycle bird: 12/13 †JCa and 12/17 ph. †KJB. [Corrected]
3785:32012-11-10Canal Park in DuluthSt. Louis(record #2012-040, vote 7-0). Juvenile. While not photographed, the record is supported by written details from a highly-knowledgeable gull observer. Accepted
3885:32012-11-28Canal Park in DuluthSt. Louis(record #2012-042, vote 7-0). Adult, photographed. This appears to be the first documented adult on record in the state. Accepted
3986:32013-02-03Lakeview Park, Two HarborsLake(record #2013-068, vote 7-0). Only the second state-record adult. Observed by at least one experienced observer. Accepted
avian
information
2013-02-032013-02-10Lake2/3, 10 Lake (fourth county record)
See documented reports still under review.
4088:912016-01-162016-02-12Canal Park, DuluthSt. Louis(record #2016-002, vote 7-0). Two first-cycle individuals, both photographed 16-18 January (The Loon 88:138-139). At least one of the two birds lingered until 12 February 2016. Accepted
avian
information
2016-01-162016-02-12St. Louis1/16-23, 2/10-12 St. Louis (fourth winter record)
Two first-cycle individuals St. Louis (Canal Park) 1/16–18 StK, ph. †PHS, ph. †JWL, m.ob., then only one from 1/19–23 m.ob. (The Loon 88:138–139). Numerous additional photos m.ob. Presumably one of the same birds was rediscovered at the same location 2/10–12 TPM, KRE, ph. JPR, ph. AiP. Additional report (presumed same bird) 2/15 Lake (Two Harbors, Agate Bay) ph. BeB, KBy, ph. JWL, m.ob.
4189:872016-02-15Agate Bay, Two HarborsLake(record #2016-053, vote 7-0). Juvenile, photographed. Accepted
MOU2016-02-15Agate Bay, Two HarborsLake(record #2016-053, vote 7-0)Accepted
avian
information
2016-02-15Lake2/15 Lake (fifth winter record)
Two first-cycle individuals St. Louis (Canal Park) 1/16–18 StK, ph. †PHS, ph. †JWL, m.ob., then only one from 1/19–23 m.ob. (The Loon 88:138–139). Numerous additional photos m.ob. Presumably one of the same birds was rediscovered at the same location 2/10–12 TPM, KRE, ph. JPR, ph. AiP. Additional report (presumed same bird) 2/15 Lake (Two Harbors, Agate Bay) ph. BeB, KBy, ph. JWL, m.ob.
4289:32016-11-07Agate Bay, Two HarborsLake(record #2016-043, vote 7-0). Juvenile, photographed. Accepted
avian
information
2016-11-07Lake11/7 Lake
Only report 11/7 Lake (first-cycle, Two Harbors, Agate Bay) ph. †ALx, JLf.
avian
information
2017-11-242017-11-25Washington11/24-25 Washington (second county record)
First-cycle seen 11/24–25 Washington (Hazen P. Mooers Park) † KIs, ph. PNi, ph. † MJM, † EzH.
4390:32017-11-25Washington County (record #2017-048Washington(record #2017-048, vote 7-0). Great find and photo documentation Accepted
4493:1112021-10-292021-11-14 Minnesota Point/Superior Entry, DuluthSt. Louis (record #2021-080, vote 7-0). Juvenile, photographed.

Accepted
4594:1152022-03-292022-03-30 Canal Park, DuluthSt. Louis (record #2022-076, vote 7-0). Apparent first-cycle, photographed. Accepted
avian
information
2022-03-292022-03-30St. Louis3/29-30 St. Louis (fifth spring record)
The first spring record of this species in over three decades was found 3/29–30 St. Louis (Canal Park) JiM, ph. ALw.
4695:32022-12-16 Lake PepinWabasha (record #2022-100, vote 7-0). Juvenile/first cycle, photographed.

Accepted
avian
information
2022-12-16Wabasha12/16 Wabasha (second county record)
One report: 12/16 Wabasha (first-cycle, Lake Pepin near Camp Lacupolis) ph. †PEJ. This is the first winter-season report since 2015.
4795:1152023-06-14 Lake WinnibigoshishCass (record #2023-094, vote 7-0). Adult, photographed. 

Accepted
avian
information
2023-06-14Cass6/14 Cass (second county record)
avian
information
2023-06-21Beltrami6/21 Beltrami (second county record)
4895:1152023-11-052023-11-07 PalmersSt. Louis (record #2023-122, vote 7-0). First cycle, photographed.

Accepted
4995:1152023-11-192023-11-22 Taconite HarborCook (record #2023-109, vote 7-0). Two first-cycle birds, photographed.

Accepted
 
 Forty-nine records: 4 spring, 2 summer, 30 fall, and 13 winter. Recorded in five of the last ten years, most recently 2023.

Notes:

The information in the above table comes from several different sources. The count in column 1 indicates which of the sources is considered the primary source.
'Accepted' MOURC entries from The MOURC Proceedings
'Not Accepted' or 'Rejected' MOURC entry from The MOURC Proceedings
Accepted MOU records assembled by David Cahlander
Sighting records for ()
Avian information from the occurrence maps, in dark red, assembled by Robert Janssen. Seasonal report for the species/season published in The Loon or The Flicker has been added.
Information from The Loon index assembled by Anthony Hertzel and David Cahlander